Protest Room

Protests under discussion

Here you can find the protests that have been filled. A protest can be on 3 different status:    1. Pre-Hearing, the fist two days, for discussion of both parties    2. Open, public discussion. Protest Room standard procedure    3. Closed, ruled by the commitee or because RAF Important Notice: Protests where the protested sailor does not show will be automatically ruled against him/her after the pre-hearing period

Legend Pre-hearing (waiting for initial agreement) Open at the Protest Room Closed after discussion Closed because protestee did not show

id	STATUS		Protester	Protestee	Subject
115907		PRE-HEARING (46 hours left)	Boathole	pastor	Boathole vs. pastor (NO) L1_1283843501_4 [3] Skillfull, but, legal?
115903		PRE-HEARING (46 hours left)	Boathole	Barman	Boathole vs. Barman (Rule 18 - Mark room) L1-aus_1283853619_aus_Sep07 [6] BOOOM! R15?
115891		PRE-HEARING (38 hours left)	Okole	aston_villa_rules	Okole vs. aston_villa_rules (R12 and R21.2) L2_1283765824_Topper [3] aston_villa_rules breaks R21.2
115889		PRE-HEARING (38 hours left)	Okole	baryla	Okole vs. baryla (R20.3) L1-aus_1283803318_EuroRegattaAlternate [8] baryla breaks R20.3 with incorrect hail
115888		PRE-HEARING (38 hours left)	Okole	SONRISAS	Okole vs. SONRISAS (Rule 21.3) L1_1283820019_F-1283820019447 [1] SONRISAS breaks R21.2 when sailing backwards.
115843		PRE-HEARING (33 hours left)	PEB	somedude	PEB vs. somedude (Rule 15 Acquiring ROW) L1-aus_1283800584_ForEdWright [3] Somedude gybes too close to PEB for PEB to avoid
115838		PRE-HEARING (32 hours left)	PEB	Guest_32	PEB vs. Guest_32 (Rule 11 Leeboat) L1-aus_1283800086_F-1283800086658 [1] Guest_32 sails down on PEB before the start
115834		PRE-HEARING (32 hours left)	StRoch	baryla	StRoch vs. baryla (If I list them I still be here tonight so foreget it =}) L1-aus_1283803318_EuroRegattaAlternate [6] Mod GOOD LUCK,
115791		PRE-HEARING (28 hours left)	ProOC	can1297	ProOC vs. can1297 (Tack) L1-aus_1283786253_F-1283786253532 [1] R15
115766		PRE-HEARING (27 hours left)	dixtroux	Popcorn	dixtroux vs. Popcorn (R13) L1-aus_1283787660_F-1283787660255 [1] Popcorn breaks R13
115761		PRE-HEARING (27 hours left)	can1297	dixtroux	can1297 vs. dixtroux (Rule 16.1 - Changing course, room) L1-aus_1283788117_F-1283788117972 [1] Propaa course
115753		PRE-HEARING (26 hours left)	dixtroux	afonsoc.n.t.	dixtroux vs. afonsoc.n.t. (NO) L1-aus_1283786253_F-1283786253532 [1] R18
115751		PRE-HEARING (26 hours left)	StRoch	rubin_hurricane_carter	StRoch vs. rubin_hurricane_carter (15) L1-aus_1283783637_regatta [5] rule 15
115654		PRE-HEARING (10 hours left)	admyride	Chinito	admyride vs. Chinito (NO) L1-euro_1283716614_only [3] 18, 11 44.2
115613		PRE-HEARING (8 hours left)	MacroMagic	DIMEDIME	MacroMagic vs. DIMEDIME (R11, R17, R44.2) L1-euro_1283713203_euro_Sep05 [6] Simple R11
115603		PRE-HEARING (3 hours left)	StRoch	RC	StRoch vs. RC (NO) L1-aus_1283705153_F-1283705153928 [1] was unable to avoid after capsize
115575		PRE-HEARING (-1 hours left)	dixtroux	radio4095	dixtroux vs. radio4095 (Tack) L1_1283651207_regatta [1] Radio tacks
105507		PRE-HEARING (-2223 hours left)	b30	saolorski	b30 vs. saolorski (10) _ [4] sailorski or port collides with b30 on starboard
115906		OPEN	ap-o	griffo	ap-o vs. griffo (Rule 18 - Mark room (!)) L1-aus_1283853619_aus_Sep07 [6] R
115864		OPEN	can1297	SailBean	can1297 vs. SailBean (NO) L1_1283812259_amer_Sep06 [8] ROOM ROOM
115788		OPEN	turkeyboat	rubin_hurricane_carter	turkeyboat vs. rubin_hurricane_carter (Rule 10 - Port-Starboard) L1-aus_1283792511_letsrace [2] tacking too close
115752		OPEN	dixtroux	filledevoile	dixtroux vs. filledevoile (Rule 11 - Overlapped, windward boat) L1-aus_1283785784_F-1283785784254 [1] R19 or R15
115678		OPEN	dixtroux	Ursus_maritimus	dixtroux vs. Ursus_maritimus (NO) L1_1283741345_F-1283741345174 [1] Gross
115663		OPEN	StRoch	ajsailing888	StRoch vs. ajsailing888 (16.1, 44.2, 11, 44.2, 10, 64.1, 44.1, 2) L1_1283725858_amer_Sep05 [1] Mess at the Start
115604		OPEN	noguer	elerik	noguer vs. elerik (NO) L2_1283659216_nzl_Sep05 [6] CAPULLO?? fair sailing
115584		OPEN	Mid_Fleet_Racer	Guest_17	Mid_Fleet_Racer vs. Guest_17 (Rule 2) L1-aus_1283696415_shoyatomizawa [1] IP ban, or guest rights for other identities?
115576		OPEN	dixtroux	optioli	dixtroux vs. optioli (Rule 11 - Overlapped, windward boat) L1_1283651207_regatta [1] Great start by optioli
115573		OPEN	dixtroux	tillerman	dixtroux vs. tillerman (Rule 11 - Overlapped, windward boat) L1_1283651207_regatta [3] Tillerman
115531		OPEN	OptimistPrime Red	WhereIsWaldo Blue	(T)OptimistPrime(GOD) vs WhereIsWaldo, rule 20.1
115527		OPEN	OptimistPrime Red	Noguer Orange	(T)OptimistPrime(GOD) vs Noguer, rule 11
115513		OPEN	noguer	can1297	noguer vs. can1297 (rule 12) L1_1283553058_amer_Sep03 [2] jibes and bum in my back
115493		OPEN	StRoch	RC	StRoch vs. huger, (2/69) L1_1283622045_rg [2] This is a protest against Huger and not RC
115486		OPEN	StRoch	whereiswaldo	StRoch vs. whereiswaldo (Rule 16.1 - Changing course, room) L2_1283611464_espanya [2] Rule 10
115477		OPEN	metaldude	JohnBouy	metaldude vs. JohnBouy (Rule 16.1, Rule 17) L2_1283605870_wea [2] no room to keep clear
115469		OPEN	Okole	polishedmarvel	Okole vs. polishedmarvel (R44.2) L1_1283553058_amer_Sep03 [6] polishedmarvel breaks R10 and does not comply with R44.2
115461		OPEN	McG	Frodo	(T)McG vs. Frodo (Rule 18) No Overlap--See picture
115324		OPEN	OptimistPrime	Gavinbpk SMW	(T)OptimistPrime(GOD) vs Gavinbpk, rule 10
115318		OPEN	Play_Up_Pompey	MikeandIke	Play_Up_Pompey vs. MikeandIke (NO) L1_1283472414_regatta [3] breaks R44.2
115296		OPEN	333	turkeyboat	333 vs. turkeyboat (R18.3) L1_1283439154_mynoseisblue [1] R18.3 at the weather mark.
115294		OPEN	Sailing_Rugger	UnwantedGuest	Sailing_Rugger vs. UnwantedGuest (Rule 10, Rule 18) L1_1283450485_nodrop [3] UG breaks both Rule 10 prior to mark zone and also Rule 18 once entered
115286		OPEN	b30	Sailing_Rugger	b30 vs. Sailing_Rugger (19.2b) L1_1283439154_mynoseisblue [3] Sailing_Rugger (SR) Failed to give room at the obstruction (tinkersailor)
115104		OPEN	McG	11kmcg	McG vs. 11kmcg (R12) L1_1283304272_start_a_daily!_lol... [1] 2 Contacts, McG spins for one...11kmg spins for 0.
115062		OPEN	Woody	Madness	(T)Woody vs Madness Rule 11
115046		OPEN	ap-o	gavinbpk	ap-o vs. gavinbpk (Rule 11 - Overlapped, windward boat) L1-aus_1283275389_F-1283275389410 [1] Bigs are slow
114709		OPEN	McG	fairhope	McG vs. fairhope (R10, R18.2(b), R19.2(b)) L1-euro_1283022009_euro_Aug28 [4] Complicated--2 boats in zone + an obstruction in the zone
114344		OPEN	rainbow_warrior	varuco	rainbow_warrior vs. varuco (Rule 11 - Overlapped, windward boat) L1-euro_1282766860_yeeeeyee [4] varuco did not keep clear after rounding mark
112891		OPEN	Boathole	OptimistPrime	(T) Boathole vs OptimistPrime- R17- Overlap broken
112060		OPEN	OptimistPrime	morph_the_cat	OptimistPrime vs. morph_the_cat (R2) L1-aus_1280916046_aus_Aug04 [4] Morph_the_Cat protests to avoid spinning
112019		OPEN	OptimistPrime	morph_the_cat	OptimistPrime vs. morph_the_cat (Rule 2 and Rule 69) L1-aus_1280919881_F-1280919881859 [1] Morph_the_cat is highly offensive

Closed Protests (only last 50)

click here for all

id STATUS Protester Protestee Subject   Jury Decision Corrected Classification Addressed rules 115901 AGREED ap-o Boathole ap-o vs. Boathole (NO) L1-aus_1283853619_aus_Sep07 [6] R?   SYSTEM Boathole RAFs 3853619_aus_Sep07 -- 115900 AGREED ap-o griffo ap-o vs. griffo (Rule 18 - Mark room (!)) L1-aus_1283853619_aus_Sep07 [6] R12   SYSTEM griffo RAFs 3853619_aus_Sep07 -- 115887 AGREED Okole Txalupa Okole vs. Txalupa (R11) L1_1283820432_F-1283820432561 [1] Taxalupa is not keeping clear as per RRS definition and breaks R11.   SYSTEM Txalupa RAFs 432_F-1283820432561 -- 115833 AGREED StRoch jRock StRoch vs. jRock (10) L1-aus_1283803318_EuroRegattaAlternate [6] I had to avoid a port boat   SYSTEM jRock RAFs 3803318_EuroRegattaAlternate -- 115731 AGREED admyride rarebreed admyride vs. rarebreed (Rule 18 - Mark room (!!)) L1-aus_1283771417_F-1283771417830 [1] 13, 10   SYSTEM admyride RAFs 3771417_F-1283771417830 -- 115696 Invalid Aussie RC Aussie vs. RC (NO) L2_1283745617_nzl_Sep06 [8] DSQ   jorj 617_nzl_Sep06 115645 AGREED dixtroux raeli dixtroux vs. raeli (NO) L1_1283725858_amer_Sep05 [3] Raeli does not comply with 44.2   SYSTEM raeli RAFs 858_amer_Sep05 -- 115597 AGREED StRoch Mid_Fleet_Racer StRoch vs. Mid_Fleet_Racer (44.1) L1-aus_1283699434_F-1283699434809 [1] Should have retired for this   SYSTEM Mid_Fleet_Racer RAFs 3699434_F-1283699434809 -- 115583 Resolved MacroMagic DIMEDIME MacroMagic vs. DIMEDIME (NO) L1-aus_1283696415_shoyatomizawa [1] R10, 44.2, R2/R69   Okole DIMEDIME breaks R10 does not comply with R44.2 and breaks rule 2 - fair sailing - Hunting 3696415_shoyatomizawa R10 R44 R2 115540 AGREED PEB polishedmarvel PEB vs. polishedmarvel (Rule 15) L1_1283639399_amer_Sep04 [2] polishedmarvel tacks too close to PEB   SYSTEM polishedmarvel RAFs 399_amer_Sep04 -- 115521 Resolved noguer DIMEDIME McG vs. DIMEDIME (R2, R11, R16.1, R21.2, R44.2, ) L1-euro_1283626804_euro_Sep04 [5] Poor form by DIMEDIME--3rd party protest   Okole DIMEDIME breaks R11 does not comply with R44.2 breaks R2 - fair sailing 83626804_euro_Sep04 R11 R44 R2 115520 Resolved noguer flow us (T)just a close 16.1 at the start   Okole Flow breaks R16.1 requests and gets an RAF -100 noguer (0) flow (-100) R16 115517 AGREED dixtroux animal dixtroux vs. animal (Rule 12 - Same tack, clear astern) L1_1283639399_amer_Sep04 [2] Animal protests to avoid spin   SYSTEM animal RAFs 399_amer_Sep04 -- 115511 AGREED McG Mid_Fleet_Racer McG vs. Mid_Fleet_Racer (R10, R14) L1-euro_1283626804_euro_Sep04 [5] McG attempts to avoid, R10 foul   SYSTEM Mid_Fleet_Racer RAFs 83626804_euro_Sep04 -- 115510 AGREED McG Bob12638 McG vs. Bob12638 (R15) L1-euro_1283626804_euro_Sep04 [3] Bob leaves no room for McG to avoid   SYSTEM Bob12638 RAFs 83626804_euro_Sep04 -- 115483 Resolved metaldude optimist1737 metaldude vs. optimist1737 (NO) L2_1283605870_wea [3] do not understand witch rule was broken?   Okole No boat broke a rule - Protest dismissed. 870_wea R2 115480 AGREED metaldude Guest_2 metaldude vs. Guest_2 (Rule 11 - Overlapped, windward boat) L2_1283605870_wea [2] -   SYSTEM metaldude RAFs 870_wea -- 115475 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) chorrisplot beano chorrisplot vs. beano (R11) L1_1283553058_amer_Sep03 [5] leeward   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 058_amer_Sep03 NO SHOW 115474 AGREED chorrisplot metaldude chorrisplot vs. metaldude (R11) L1-aus_1283508014_aus_Sep03 [4] no exoneration at mark for r11 breach   SYSTEM metaldude RAFs 3508014_aus_Sep03 -- 115470 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) MacroMagic srsailing MacroMagic vs. srsailing (R11. R16.1) L1-euro_1283540405_euro_Sep03 [1] What did I do   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 83540405_euro_Sep03 NO SHOW 115452 Resolved admyride hikemore admyride vs. hikemore (15) L1_1283563529_F-1283563529386 [1] not enough room   Okole hikemore breaks R15 requests and gets an RAF - Pezza42 breaks R10 529_F-1283563529386 R10 R15 115422 Resolved USA16393 afonsoc.n.t. USA16393 vs. afonsoc.n.t. (R10) L1-aus_1283522585_nodrop [3] WOW WOW   Okole afonsoc.n.t breaks R21.3 & retires to exonerate. USA16393 breaks R16.1 3522585_nodrop R16 R21 115415 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) StRoch DinghyBoy StRoch vs. DinghyBoy (10, 18, 11. ) _ [4] I am not sure   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. NO SHOW 115407 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) turkeyboat poti turkeyboat vs. poti (NO) L1-aus_1283524345_Friday=Yeow [1] 18 and 44   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 3524345_Friday=Yeow NO SHOW 115398 Resolved Boathole grits430 Boathole vs. grits430 (R16.1) L1-euro_1283454006_euro_Sep02 [1] Startboard tack being Port   Okole Boathole breaks R11 83454006_euro_Sep02 R11 115397 Resolved Boathole orageruffy09 Boathole vs. orageruffy09 (R11) L1-aus_1283502636_BORAT [5] windward/leward   Okole orageruffy09 breaks R11 3502636_BORAT R11 115389 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) Okole me_pro_sailor Okole vs. me_pro_sailor (R13, R11, R18.2.b and R44.2.) L1_1283481738_F-1283481738326 [1] me_pro_sailor breaks R13, then R11, then R11 again, then R18.2.b and does not comply with R44.2   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 738_F-1283481738326 NO SHOW 115345 Resolved esp1736 cooker esp1736 vs. cooker (Rule 20) L2_1283492599_F-1283492599287 [1] abuse   Okole cooker breaks R11 twice does not comply with R44.2 599_F-1283492599287 R11 R44 115343 Resolved esp1736 cooker esp1736 vs. cooker (NO) L2_1283491352_F-1283491352881 [1] reset???!!   Okole cooker resets a race inappropriately, lies about it, so gets a DSQ -300 and stays on restricted rights. 352_F-1283491352881 R2 R69 115323 Resolved Frodo OptimistPrime (T)Frodo vs. OptimistPrime, Rule 13   Okole OptimistPrime breaks R13 requests and gets an RAF Frodo (0) OptimistPrime (-100) R13 115319 AGREED Play_Up_Pompey animal Play_Up_Pompey vs. animal (Rule 18 - Mark room (!)) L1-euro_1283454006_euro_Sep02 [5] Windward boat   SYSTEM animal RAFs 83454006_euro_Sep02 -- 115306 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) alpripe roots alpripe vs. roots (Rule 16.1 - Changing course, room) L1-euro_1283454006_euro_Sep02 [4] Impossible avoid colision   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 83454006_euro_Sep02 NO SHOW 115191 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) Play_Up_Pompey lasers Play_Up_Pompey vs. lasers (Rule 11 - Overlapped, windward boat) L1-euro_1283374238_motutapu [2] not keeping clear   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 83374238_motutapu NO SHOW 115151 Resolved metaldude kutaychenko metaldude vs. kutaychenko (Rule 11 & 2) L1_1283353691_F-1283353691554 [1] boats on same tack penalties owing   Okole kutaychencko breaks R11 and abuses the protest system in breach of R2 691_F-1283353691554 R11 R2 115148 Resolved metaldude kutaychenko metaldude vs. kutaychenko (Rule 11 Rule 2) L1_1283353691_F-1283353691554 [1] boats on the same tack overlapped   aestela Kutaychenko is not longer a user of SailX. 691_F-1283353691554 R69 115144 Resolved turkeyboat turnedo turkeyboat vs. turnedo (Rule 18 - Mark room (!!)) L1_1283354223_F-1283354223016 [1] 18.2   Okole turkeyboat breaks R18.2.b spins to exonerate - protest dismissed 223_F-1283354223016 115133 Resolved Bluenose Windward91 Bluenose vs. Windward91 (RRS 23.2 and RRS 2) L1_1283345114_F-1283345114486 [1] Windward91 breaks RRS 23.2 and 2   Okole Windward91 breaks R23.2 and R2 - fair sailing so gets a DSQ -300 and 2WBFR. 114_F-1283345114486 R23 R2 115106 AGREED McG bearsailing McG vs. bearsailing (R11, R44.2) L1_1283304272_start_a_daily!_lol... [2] Non compliance with R44.2   SYSTEM bearsailing RAFs 272_start_a_daily!_lol... -- 115088 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) Play_Up_Pompey Windward91 Play_Up_Pompey vs. Windward91 (NO) L1_1283298294_rangitoto [4] random protests   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 294_rangitoto NO SHOW 115087 Resolved Aussie Windward91 Aussie vs. Windward91 (NO) L1_1283298294_rangitoto [4] Reset R2   Okole Windward91 resets inappropriately so gets a DSQ -300 and 2WBFR 294_rangitoto R2 115086 Resolved Aussie Windward91 Aussie vs. Windward91 (NO) L1_1283297667_F-1283297667300 [1] Reset R2   Okole Windward91 resets inappropriately so gets a DSQ -300 and 2WBFR 667_F-1283297667300 R2 115083 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) Aussie Windward91 Aussie vs. Windward91 (NO) L1_1283297667_F-1283297667300 [1] Reset R2   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 667_F-1283297667300 NO SHOW 115041 CLOSED(NO-SHOW) Flash Guest_46 Flash vs. Guest_46 (Rule 15) L1-aus_1283268104_nodrop [2] Flash protest guest 46 and G46 tell me I abuse   SYSTEM System closes, no-show. 3268104_nodrop NO SHOW 114979 Resolved esp1736 Jswallow esp1736 vs. Jswallow (NO) L1_1283230751_ue [3] resets   Okole jswallow resets races inappropriately so gets a DSQ -300 and 2WBFR 751_ue R2 114973 Resolved k11 rodhy k11 vs. rodhy (Rule 15 - Acquiring Right-Of-Way) L1_1283222527_bigrigknowsall [2] The third of three protests against rodhy - R15 or R13 and poss R2.   Okole rodhy breaks R13 and R2 527_bigrigknowsall R13 R2 114972 Resolved k11 rodhy k11 vs. rodhy (Tack R13) L1_1283222527_bigrigknowsall [2] Tacked and did not reach Close hauled before collision.   Okole rodhy breaks R13 abuses the protest system in breach of R2 so gets a DSQ -300 and 2WBFR 527_bigrigknowsall R13 R2 114971 Resolved k11 rodhy k11 vs. rodhy (Rule 10 - Port-Starboard R\" conduct.) L1_1283220690_piripi [4] First of three where rodhy protests when in wrong   Okole rodhy breaks rule 10 abuses the protest system in breach of R2 so gets a DSQ -300 points and 2WBFR 690_piripi R10 R2 114965 Resolved McG mjcag McG vs. mjcag (R2) L1-euro_1283194808_eur_Aug30 [4] I do believe this is not legal...   Okole mjcag breaks R2 83194808_eur_Aug30 R2 114963 Resolved esp1736 Windward91 esp1736 vs. Windward91 (NO) L1-euro_1283202633_ayala_no [1] reset is fun?   Okole Windward91 resets a race inappropriately so gets a DSQ -300 and 2WBFR 83202633_ayala_no R2 114960 Resolved esp1736 ap-o esp1736 vs. ap-o (NO) L1-euro_1283200168_eu [4] resets is fun   Okole ap-o resets a race inappropriately 83200168_eu R2